Sunday, June 27, 2010

Book Review the First

Goth Girl Rising by Barry Lyga

The sequel to The Amazing Adventures of Fanboy and Goth Girl, Goth Girl Rising is a book that I feel extremely compelled to talk about, but not necessarily recommend. Ladies and gentlemen, this is a book with a lot of flaws. It's highly wrist-to-forehead melodramatic; the whole book is damn well marinated in angst, and while I follow the logic of Lyga's decision to use a first person narrative, I don't think it worked as well as he thought it would.

Kyra, (aka Goth Girl) the protagonist of the novel, is not what I would personally consider a realistic character. The single way I can think to describe her is 'pissed as hell'. Her anger with the world at large is seemingly rooted in the death of her mother from cancer, but she is the angriest person I've ever encountered in fiction or otherwise. It took me until roughly halfway though the novel to realize that it was becoming painful to read due to the fact I just wanted to give this girl a hug and a slap across the face. Since Kyra needs something to be enraged about, she creates her own revenge situation when nothing better appears to occupy herself with.

For me, this is one thing that sticks out in my mind as stupid; the novel revolves around Kyra planning a 'cut off the nose to spite the face' venture over petty and trivial details that stew in her head.

However, for all the many faults of this book, I must admit that Kyra's narrative has a lot of opinions that stray eerily parallel to my own. Kyra's ire covers everything from woman's rights, gender patterns, the 'fad' of girls kissing girls, why girls love geeks, goth subculture, and hypocrisy of pop culture. So for all I want to disparage against this novel, the fact that every angsty monologue carries this genuine question - a seed of truth - however cloaked in teenage animosity it may be, left me haunted and well... kind of shaken.

Final verdict: Trys to be goth so much it hurts.

Books Read: 20
Reviews: 1

No comments:

Post a Comment