Sunday, June 27, 2010

Ghosts of Manhattan by George Mann

The last review I posted (yes, the one directly underneath this review) is also a George Mann novel and - this says a lot about how observant I can be - I've only just realized the fact that they are both by George Mann. In all fairness, I did not read them back to back, but none the less, I'm feeling a little silly right now. This however, does solve the mystery of why I found The Affinity Bridge less than engaging regardless of the stellar content. It also answers my questioning if it was just me, or the writing, that had my attention wandering. What I couldn't quite put my finger on in Affinity Bridge, was what I noticed about Ghosts of Manhattan; one slightly off ingredient.

Like watching a mechanical doll dance, everything is there, everything moves the way it's supposed to... and yet...

I want to say that George Mann comes from writing screenplays. Now, I must put this statement into context: I know nothing about George Mann as a person or a writer. I don't know his background and my speculations are solely for my own amusement.

The opinion is based on what I noticed about Like Water for Chocolate, written by a screenwriter, the writing style is completely visually dependant. It begs for a film adaptation - which I believe Water for Chocolate received actually. Due to the dependence on visuals that words alone don't get, the writing comes across as shallow. No matter how good the story is, it still feels shallow.

Though described as 'steampunk' a couple gadgets and alternative history does not a steampunk make. Ghosts for Manhattan is Batman meets Noir. It's shallow and action packed and if that's what you like, you'll enjoy this book. If you look for something deeper in your prose of choice, well, you're just out of luck.

Final Verdict: Unless you really have a craving for Batman-like plot lines, wait for the film.

Books Read: 21
Reviews: 3

No comments:

Post a Comment